Tensions erupted on Fox News’ The Five when Greg Gutfeld went after co-host and Democratic strategist Jessica Tarlov for what he saw as downplaying the radicalization of Charlie Kirk’s suspected shooter.

The clash quickly turned personal as Gutfeld accused Tarlov of deflecting and refusing to confront the political motivations behind the attack. He argued that ignoring the ideological extremism was not only dishonest but dangerous, while Tarlov defended her position, insisting that speculation without full details could inflame the situation further. The fiery exchange left the panel divided, with viewers taking sides online — some praising Gutfeld for calling it out directly, while others supported Tarlov’s more cautious approach.