Have you ever watched a TV show or film where you whole-heartedly believed that a non-American actor or actress was from the States because of their American accent? Well, you’re not alone because when Reddit user u/jma7400 asked: “Who is one actor or actress who had an amazing American accent, and you were surprised they were not American?” over four thousand people provided their thoughts. Here’s what they had to say below:

1. “Christian Bale.”

2. “Melanie Lynskey.

3. “Idris Elba.”

4. “Toni Collette.”

5. “Hugh Laurie, 

6. “Margot Robbie.”

7. “Andrew Garfield.”